Saturday, November 8, 2014

Competitive Gaming, Let's have a chat


Competitive games. I personally have mixed feelings towards them. Games by design are intended to bring people together. As it is said in VGHS, "It's all about the game." And sometimes games are competitive. I get that, it's human nature. Yet sometimes, either the games themselves or the people who play them make it about winning. I grew up playing Magic: The Gathering and Halo, yet I don't like the competition portion of your game.

I know and understand that competitive gaming is often times driven by business. I get that. Why do Magic: The Gathering, Madden (and other sports games), Call of Duty all have new products release annually? In the case of Trading Card Games it has been the case for years, but in the case of Video Games, Madden, I'm pointing fingers at you. Yes, "technically" the rosters in sports teams change year from year, but your mechanics do not. Yet you shut down your online servers to old games a month or two after the new one releases. You have made the game about the competition, rather than about the game. Call of Duty, Assassin's Creed, Battlefield, why did they follow suit? Because professional gamers play those games and want updated versions of games they already own? There are minimal, if any actual changes that occur. Yet we keep buying them.

Competition reduces the fun of actually playing the game for me. When you're out to win, you don't care that you're having fun unless you are winning. So why? Why is the gaming market flooded with competitive games and tournaments around them? Let the cooperative, story tellers, social gamers, and the casual gamers have their fun too, and I liked. If you look at the sales and advertisements though, the competitive games wins in Television and on YouTube and such. Story driven games rely on their story to sell the game. Co-operative games rely on people who want to play together, and replay-ability.  Competitive games rely on repetition for success in them, to get great at Call of Duty requires you to play it virtually endlessly. Dungeons and Dragons is not like that. You meet with your group once every so often and tell a story together. Replay-ability is higher, as you aren't doing the exact same thing over and over and over.

I'm not saying that competitive games are bad, just that they aren't for me, as they rely on shady business model and even worse on repetition. I like story driven games like D&D, Dragon Age, The Last of Us, and co-operative games like Forbidden Island and Pandemic. Everyone has their cup of tea, and competitive games aren't mine. But I thought I'd point out some things that competitive games relies on for sales...